| Contestant | User | Tribe | Finish | Jury Vote |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Josh | Mister.. E. | Merged Tribe | Quit 1st Jury Member 8th Place |
Penelope |
| Scarlet | Fyrexx | 2nd Voted Out 2nd Jury Member 7th Place |
Penelope | |
| Madison | Sunslicer2 | 3rd Voted Out 3rd Jury Member 6th Place |
Penelope | |
| Kristal | BrunoSomebody | 4th Voted Out 4th Jury Member 5th Place |
Penelope | |
| Tanner | Jake R | 5th Voted Out 5th Jury Member 4th Place |
Penelope | |
| Noah | Owenandheatherfan | 1st Voted Out 9th Place |
Marty | |
| Returned Episode 4 | ||||
| 6th Voted Out 6th Jury Member 3rd Place | ||||
| Marty | Nalyd Renrut | Runner-Up | - | |
| Penelope | Nduke | Sole Firevivor | - |
| # | Contestant | 1 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1st | Penelope | Noah | Scarlet | Madison | Noah | Tanner | Noah | WINNER |
| 2nd | Marty | Noah | Scarlet | Madison | Kristal | Tanner | Noah | RUNNER-UP |
| 3rd | Noah | ? | OUT | ? | ? | ? | OUT | |
| 4th | Tanner | ? | ? | ? | ? | OUT | ||
| 5th | Kristal | Noah | Scarlet | Madison | OUT | |||
| 6th | Madison | Noah | Tanner | OUT | ||||
| 7th | Scarlet | ? | OUT | |||||
| 8th | Josh | X | OUT | |||||
| 9th | Noah | OUT |